Principles that Help Make Online Courses Successful

Beverley McGuire has taught online courses for 10 years, and she’s been a student in them for five. From those experiences, she’s learned a few things about making online courses effective. She’s also conversant with current research and collaborates with colleagues. From that knowledge and

Read More »
Group of University students in lecture hall

Five Types of Student Questions and Sample Responses

Students ask all different kinds of questions. Some are on the money—good, honest queries about content that they don’t understand or want to know more about. Other student questions are more difficult to handle. It’s good to have some strategies lined up for when these

Read More »
male professor reviews course evaluations

What Can We Learn from End-of-Course Evaluations?

No matter how much we debate the issue, end-of-course evaluations count. How much they count is a matter of perspective. They matter if you care about teaching. They frustrate you when you try to figure out what they mean. They haven’t changed; they are regularly

Read More »
Students at university lecture raise hands to ask questions

Conducting In-Class Reviews Effectively

Good study skills are the key to successful performance on exams in college, and good study skills are what many of today’s college students don’t have. We can spend time pontificating about who bears the responsibility for these absent skills. We can philosophize about who

Read More »
note taking

A Handout for Students on Note-taking

When it comes to class notes, we all know that students would much rather get the teacher’s notes or PowerPoints than write their own for lots of reasons. They’re getting the content straight from the expert. It makes note-taking less work, and they don’t have

Read More »
international students

Students’ Use of Their Own Language: Breaking Down Barriers

“Language influences thought and action. The words we use to describe things—to ourselves and others—affect how we and they think and act.” (Weimer, 2015).

Learners can be empowered or suppressed by the language(s) used in our classrooms and other learning spaces. Given the increasingly divisive

Read More »
tired teacher

Waking up to Tired Teaching

I have been wanting to do a blog post on tired teaching for some time now. Concerns about burnout are what’s motivating me. Teachers can reach a place where teaching does nothing for them or their students. They don’t just wake up one morning and

Read More »
Archives

Get the Latest Updates

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

Magna Digital Library
wpChatIcon
Editor's Note: This article launches a new column in the newsletter. I'm picking pesky issues without easy answers and inviting individuals to share thoughts about them. Lolita Paff launches the series with thoughts about how teachers and students define hard courses. --MEW   If you asked students to tell you what makes a course hard, what would they say? Would their answers be the same as yours? Would it be a problem if they weren't? What makes a course hard? Draeger, del Prado Hill, and Mahler (2015) conducted campus-wide surveys, focus groups, and interviews to ascertain students' definition of academic rigor. Students explain hard courses in terms of workload, grading standards, level of interest, and perceived relevance. These results contrast with faculty definitions (Draeger, del Prado Hill, Hunter, & Mahler, 2013), which focused on active learning, meaningful content, higher-order thinking, and appropriate expectations. These findings confirm my experience: Teachers and students are not on the same page when it comes to what makes a course hard. Does it matter? This mismatch has significant implications for learning. Let me explain with an analogy. Monique wants to lose weight. She plans to eat less and exercise more. She hires Carmen, a personal trainer, to help her with a cardio program. Like many people, Monique believes less food and more cardio are all she needs. And for the short term, she's right. The session starts with ten minutes of cardio, but then to Monique's surprise, Carmen takes her over to the weight machines. Monique protests—she wants to burn fat. Carmen persists and Monique begrudgingly complies, but with disappointment and less enthusiasm. She finishes the session without understanding why weight training is a necessary part of successful weight loss programs. I have a lot of students like Monique. They've paid good money for my classes. They're willing to work, even to sweat. But like Monique, their expectations and understanding of what's required are incomplete. Monique and Carmen aren't on the same page and neither are my students and I. Carmen does know what's best for her client, just as teachers know what's best for students. Carmen's the expert and assumes Monique understands that and will accept the plan. Carmen doesn't think there's a need to explain why weight training is necessary. She also doesn't develop the weight loss plan with Monique, which would have given her a great opportunity to explain why the plan needed to include weights. Carmen—and many teachers—think like experts, forgetting that novices see and approach learning very differently. If teachers and students understand “hard” courses differently, that bodes poorly for the relationship between them. What can teachers do? Martin et al. (2008) investigated students' perceptions of hard and easy courses across engineering programs. Two of their strategies have broad application. There is value in initiating conversations with students about learning and how that relates to definitions of “hard” courses. We can't dispel misperceptions if we're unaware. The goal of the conversations isn't to negotiate watering down the course, make grading easier, or lower expectations. It's to give students a voice so that what makes a course hard is understood by everyone and the definitions move closer to being mutually acceptable. References: Draeger, J., P., del Prado Hill, & Mahler, R. (2015). Developing a student concept of academic rigor. Innovation in Higher Education, 40, 215–228. Draeger, J., del Prado Hill, P., Hunter, L. R., & Mahler, R. (2013). The anatomy of academic rigor: The story of one institutional journey. Innovative Higher Education, 38, 267–279.? Martin, J. H., Hands, K. B., Lancaster, S. M., Trytten, D. A., & Murphy, T. J. (2008). Hard but not too hard: Challenging courses and engineering students. College Teaching, 56(2), 107–113.